When Is Surgery Indicated for a Hiatal Hernia?

Originally published November 20, 2026

Last updated November 20, 2026

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Search more articles

News & Magazine

3D rendering of an axial hiatus hernia type 1.

When large hiatal hernias introduce the risk of serious complications, they become an indication for surgery themselves.

For most patients with a hiatal hernia, watchful waiting offers a workable standard of care: If and when medications no longer suppress gastroesophageal reflux (GERD) symptoms, or if evidence of esophageal damage such as ulcers or Barrett’s esophagus emerges, elective surgery can enter the discussion as a next step. 

But in patients with large or paraesophageal hernias — in which the stomach squeezes through the diaphragm into the chest alongside the esophagus — the potential for complications tips the balance away from surgery as an elective measure and toward it as an emergency one. 

Dr. Lipham in a white medical coat against a grey background.
John C. Lipham, MD

“When a hernia gets bigger than 5 to 6 centimeters, or maybe one-third or even the entire stomach herniates into the chest, the hernia itself becomes an indication for surgery because it’s just going to get bigger and create risks that require intervention,” explains John C. Lipham, MD, a gastrointestinal surgeon with USC Surgery and the USC Digestive Health Institute, part of Keck Medicine of USC. 

The risks of a large hiatal hernia 

Even before such risks arise, large paraesophageal hernias take a toll on quality of life. Patients may develop shortness of breath as the stomach occupies more space that would otherwise accommodate the lungs. With so much of the stomach now in the chest, they may also experience early satiety and trouble eating. And they often experience chest pain as the stomach becomes distended in the chest. 

“Many patients even present to the emergency room thinking that they’re having a heart attack,” Lipham notes, “when what they’ve really got is reflux and a big hiatal hernia.” 

Large paraesophageal hernias can also precipitate internal bleeding and ulcers. Friction and twisting of the stomach as it pushes through the hiatal opening cause trauma, exposing the stomach to acid and leading to sores known as Cameron lesions. “Patients don’t always know they’re bleeding,” Lipham points out, “but they slowly become anemic over time.” 

Yet the most concerning risk of large paraesophageal hernias is the possibility that the stomach may twist within the chest so much that it becomes strangulated and incarcerated, starving the trapped tissue of blood and predisposing it to necrosis, potential perforation of the stomach wall and subsequent infection. 

“This results in emergency surgery with a very high mortality rate — upwards of 40% in some studies,” Lipham says. “Usually, we have to remove a large section of the stomach and then hook up the intestine directly to the end of the esophagus.” 

Finding a large-hernia fix that lasts

Surgical treatments for paraesophageal hernias aim primarily at returning the herniated stomach to the abdominal cavity and reinforcing the weakened crural muscles surrounding the esophagus, and they typically involve minimally invasive laparoscopic or robotic methods. 

But a significant goal for surgeons like Lipham isn’t just to repair the hernia but to reduce the likelihood that it will develop again. 

As he explains, “Whether in the case of surgery for GERD, small hernias or these bigger paraesophageal hernias, all have an inherent recurrence rate of both the hernia and the reflux. And the Achilles’ heel of these surgeries isn’t failure of the lower-esophageal sphincter fix, but the tendency of the hiatal hernia repair itself to stretch out over time such that recurrence becomes easier.” 

With recurrence rates at about 10 years post-surgery roughly 20%, Lipham says, “For the past couple of decades, we’ve been exploring different techniques for reinforcing the diaphragm to decrease that chance of recurrence.” 

Among the solutions under consideration are absorbable synthetic and biologic meshes that support hernia repairs, particularly in cases of large defects or crural-muscle atrophy. “And more recently,” Lipham notes, “we’ve been looking at platelet-rich plasma, or PRP, which contains a lot of growth factors and compounds that stimulate wound healing.” 

To harvest these compounds, a sample of the patient’s blood is centrifuged, separating the red and white blood cells from the plasma. Concentrated platelets are collected from the latter and injected or applied directly into the crural tissue and surgical mesh during hernia repair surgery to strengthen integration. 

“We’re still in the midst of our clinical trial using PRP,” Lipham says of his Keck Medicine team, “and I can say preliminarily that it appears to be lowering recurrence rates. But until we have three to five years of follow-up data — which we should have within the next year or two — we won’t know for sure.” 

He’s hopeful, and aware of how important trials like this are. 

“If you’d asked me 15 or 20 years ago,” he observes, “I would have said that we only see these types of hernias in elderly patients — in their 70s and 80s. But now we frequently see patients in their 40s and 50s with paraesophageal hernias.” For them, a means of achieving a durable repair can’t arrive fast enough. 

Refer a Patient

The pioneering care provided by Keck Medicine of USC physicians stands at the forefront of leading-edge medicine. Learn how our specialists can help with your toughest cases.
Use Our Quick Referral Form

Topics

Kimberly J. Decker
Kimberly J. Decker
Kimberly J. Decker is a freelance writer for Keck Medicine of USC.

Search more articles

News & Magazine